Why Republicans Lose: Feckless Leaders and Consultants Paid Win or Lose


Why Republicans Lose: Feckless Leaders and Consultants Paid Win or Lose: Jim Pfaff on the Conservative Commandos Radio Show | Nov 11, 2026

Published: November 11, 2026
Network: Conservative Commandos Radio Show
Analysis: Conservative Caucus President Jim Pfaff


Republicans lose because the people who run the party pay no price for losing. The Republican Congress sat on its hands for a year and a half after the One Big Beautiful Bill passed, and then it reelected John Thune. The consultants who placed the ads will be hired again in two years, “win, lose, or draw.”

The election result has very little to do with Donald Trump. Gas prices were a big part of it. So was corruption in government, which pre-election and post-election polling shows was a major issue in all of the key states. That issue has its center in Congress, because Republicans did nothing and did not change their ways.

Jim Pfaff, president of The Conservative Caucus, laid this out on the Conservative Commandos Radio Show with Rick Trader and Sharron Angle on November 11, 2026. He has been chief of staff to two congressmen and ran a political consulting business, and he has watched both failures from the inside.

Topics Covered


Congress Is the Weak Part

Pfaff has said it on that program many times: “the weak part of the Trump agenda has been Republicans in Congress.” The system is broken down and nothing gets done because, in his words, “Republicans are feckless cowards,” or they do stupid things, or they sit around and say what John Thune said: that Republicans want to work with Democrats to find solutions for the American people.

Thune is the failure who brought about this result. The Senate reelected him anyway.

Massie Went After the Wrong Man

Thomas Massie has decided to go on a vengeance tour, and it is a disappointment. His record has been beneficial overall to the conservative movement, to liberty and to constitutional order. He used to say that members of Congress stay too long and treat the pin that gets them past every security checkpoint like “my precious.” Pfaff, who was his chief of staff, said it plainly: “I think he’s been wearing the ring lately.”

There is no substance to any of his articles of impeachment against Pete Hegseth. The War Powers Resolution of 1973 is unconstitutional, but it is what Congress decided to do. It put the war powers into guidelines a president could follow, and Donald Trump followed every one of them.

Going after Hegseth was also cowardly. If Massie really thought these articles rose to the level of high crimes and misdemeanors, he would have brought them against the President. He is not willing to take the President on, and that shows the charge is not as serious as he claims.

The pity is what Massie could have been. If there had been 220 Thomas Massies in Congress when Trump became president this time, the whole Trump agenda would have passed. The one thing Trump would not have gotten is authorization for the war, which is a real policy disagreement between the two men.

Kansas Shows How It Happens

Roger Marshall lost his Senate seat in a very red state. He came in under false auspices in 2016, when a campaign run by Jeff Roe of Axiom Strategies took out Tim Huelskamp by calling him an establishment Republican. Huelskamp was the opposite; establishment Republicans constantly worked against him. Pfaff had worked for Huelskamp and had left the office by then.

Marshall has been a weak candidate ever since. He did not work the state. His opponent did opposition research on collections at his medical practice, in ways that seemed scammy to Pfaff, and put it out well. Marshall did not answer it well and did not raise money, and he was badly outspent.

“This race in particular epitomizes why Republicans lose because they don’t care about the people that they represent.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus

Republicans like Marshall do not advocate for their voters from a Trumpian perspective, and then they sit back as though things are owed to them. He lost to Adam Hamilton, who leads the largest United Methodist church in the country, in Johnson County near Kansas City, and whose views are hardly different from James Talarico’s. Kansas will live with that for six years. It is the RINOs’ fault, and it is John Thune’s fault.

Election Integrity Without Sour Grapes

Much about this election looks strange. With multiple-day elections and extensive mail balloting in most states, nobody can be very confident in the outcomes until the country goes back to same-day voting with a paper trail. Election integrity is one of the focuses of The Conservative Caucus, and it is not going to back down.

Some perspective is needed too. In 2010 there was a similar shift in every county in the country, toward Republicans. Democrat turnout did rise this year. Whether problems along the way added to it is not yet known, and Pfaff is not convinced one way or the other.

California is a different matter. Spencer Pratt was selected out of the Los Angeles mayor’s race. Nithya Raman, now the mayor-elect, was way down on primary election day, and ballots were stuffed to keep Pratt from getting a chance. That is why vigilance is always required. It is also why the Republican leadership in Congress cannot be let off the hook. Republicans angered the American public, and the public was angrier at the GOP Congress than at Donald Trump.

The Consultants Get Paid Either Way

The $5 billion Republicans spent on campaigns is largely transfer money. It goes to predetermined GOP consultants who place television ads and send direct mail. The House and Senate campaign committees, and in many ways the RNC, have their preferred consultants. Those consultants carry no risk of loss. They make the media buys and collect, and they get the next round of campaigns even after losing the last one.

Two of them, Chris LaCivita and Susie Wiles, got very wealthy when Donald Trump ran in 2024. By Pfaff’s recollection, LaCivita personally netted $20 million to his company. This is more corrupt than members of Congress trading stocks on insider information.

“The same consultants are going to come in and make the same money 2 years from now, win, lose, or draw.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus

Democrats have always been better at the things in campaigns that work. The voter they target gets more than an ad. He gets a knock at the door and a direct phone call, and he is connected to an organization. What Democrats send is not partisan material. It is material on issues they have identified with that voter, because their data is so good. Republican data is not. And as Pfaff put it, “grassroots does not make money,” so the party does not do the organizing that is necessary. The Conservative Caucus spent somewhere between $3 million and $5 million this cycle and put it into a high level of targeting.

Lobbyists Run Washington

Stephen Miller has replaced Susie Wiles, and it should have happened earlier. Miller is a doer with a good political mind, and “if you want a wartime consigliere, that’s the guy to do it.” The decisions will still be Donald Trump’s.

Wiles is competent and capable, and she brought some positives. But Calley Means said on Joe Rogan’s program that new guidelines on non-processed food were shut down by Wiles. They were guidelines, not a regulation, and they could have saved the lives of many children. According to Means, she said, “I need the sugar money.” The sugar lobby is one of the worst in Washington. It is headed by Ryan Weston, and everyone on the Agriculture Committee is scared to death of him.

Lobbying is not a crime and should not be prohibited. But in the 19th century an American citizen could walk into the White House and talk to the President’s staff. That connection went away through the 20th century and now does not exist at all. Washington is a bubble. Members of Congress who do not want to lose a $174,000 paycheck do what lobbyists say, and about a third of them go on to $300,000 or $400,000 paychecks at lobby firms when they are done.

None of this changes without a radical change in the way the Republican Party organizes itself at the leadership level. Until then the same people will lose the same way and be paid for it. Watch the full interview above.

Key Takeaways

  1. Congress Is the Weak Part – Pfaff has said it on that program many times: “the weak part of the Trump agenda has been Republicans in Congress.” The system is broken down and nothing gets done because, in his words, “Republicans are feckless cowards,” or they do stupid things, or they sit around and say what John Thune said: that Republicans want to work with Democrats to find solutions for the American people.
  2. Massie Went After the Wrong Man – Thomas Massie has decided to go on a vengeance tour, and it is a disappointment.
  3. Kansas Shows How It Happens – Roger Marshall lost his Senate seat in a very red state.
  4. Election Integrity Without Sour Grapes – Much about this election looks strange.
  5. The Consultants Get Paid Either Way – The $5 billion Republicans spent on campaigns is largely transfer money.
  6. Lobbyists Run Washington – Stephen Miller has replaced Susie Wiles, and it should have happened earlier.

Share This Analysis

Join The Conservative Caucus

Help us fight for election integrity and expose government corruption. Your support makes investigative journalism like this possible.

DONATE TODAY

About The Conservative Caucus:
The Conservative Caucus is a grassroots public policy action organization, formed in 1974. Headed by President Jim Pfaff, the Caucus is committed to advancing free enterprise, limited government, and traditional values.

Originally broadcast Nov 11, 2026 on the Conservative Commandos Radio Show with Rick Trader and Sharron Angle.

Other Articles

The Conservative Caucus Logo

DONATE TO THE CONSERVATIVE CAUCUS AND HELP US TAKE BACK OUR COUNTRY.

Our mission is to create a grassroots conservative network, uniting people of widely varying backgrounds in peaceable defense of our country, our Constitution, and our common values rooted in liberty and equal rights.


Your donation to The Conservative Caucus is more than a financial contribution. It’s a stand for the principles that have made our nation great: liberty, prosperity, and the rule of law. When you give, you’re not just supporting an organization. You’re supporting a return to the foundational ideals that have guided our country from the very beginning.

Our goal at The Conservative Caucus is to champion these timeless principles in the policy arena and beyond. But we can’t do it without you. Your generous donation allows us to continue our vital work – influencing policy, holding lawmakers accountable, advocating for fiscal responsibility, and fighting to preserve the constitutional freedoms that underpin our great nation.

The road ahead may be challenging, but together, we can reclaim the vision our Founding Fathers had for America. Whether it’s a one-time gift or a recurring monthly contribution, your donation makes a real, tangible difference. Stand with us today. Help us take back our country. Your support could be the very thing that tips the balance in favor of a brighter, stronger, more conservative future for America.

Thank you for your unwavering commitment to our cause. Together, we will make a difference.

The Conservative Caucus Favcon

JOIN TCC IN STOPPING THE ATTACKS ON OUR FREEDOM.

If the liberals have their way, our speech will no longer be free, our guns will become outlawed, and every other right we cherish will be endangered. Let your voice be heard and tell our government to uphold the Constitution, and continue to keep America the land of the free and the home of the brave.

THE PLEDGE:

I join the overwhelming majority of conservative Americans to demand that the government no longer violate our Constitutional rights.

I stand with all Americans and affirm our Constitutional rights and urge all candidates and elected officials to affirm the same.

The Conservative Caucus Logo

Mr. Peter J. Thomas

Chairman

Peter J. Thomas is a veteran conservative political strategist and seasoned policy expert dedicated to upholding the principles of the Constitution and democracy. As a founder and the chairman of the Conservative Caucus, he has played a pivotal role in promoting and shaping the conservative agenda across the nation for over half a century.

Peter’s distinguished career includes key presidential appointments under Presidents Reagan, Bush Sr., and Bush Jr. Under President Reagan, he served as the New England Regional Administrator of the General Services Administration. During Bush Sr.’s administration, he was the Special Assistant to the Secretary of Small Business. Under Bush Jr., he rose to the position of Acting Assistant Secretary for Administration in the Department of Agriculture. Additionally, Peter gained invaluable insight into Congress as Chief of Staff to Rep. Peter Torkildsen (R-MA).

Peter’s dedication to conservative values is further demonstrated by his tenure as the National Field Director of TCC in its early years, when he oversaw chapters in most congressional districts. His diverse experience also includes, founding and presiding over the Massachusetts Foundation for Economic Research, serving as director of communications for Papa Gino’s restaurants, and earning accolades as a leading sales representative for State Mutual of America.