Republicans in Congress Lost the Election, and the Senate Kept John Thune: Jim Pfaff on The Dan Carroll Show | Nov 11, 2026
Published: November 11, 2026
Network: 700 WLW
Analysis: Conservative Caucus President Jim Pfaff
Republicans in Congress lost this election. The Senate passed the One Big Beautiful Bill and then sat on its hands for a year and a half, with nothing to show except a housing bill nobody is talking about that expanded government anyway. Then Senate Republicans voted to keep John Thune as their leader, after one of the worst losses any Republican majority has had.
The war is the explanation many are offering. It is not the real one. The war in Iran had a big effect on one part of the electorate, voters under 30. For everyone else the numbers before and after the election say the same thing. The economy was the first problem. Very close behind it in key states was the corruption in Washington, and the fact that Washington does not care about the lives of the people in this country.
Jim Pfaff, president of The Conservative Caucus, gave that reading on The Dan Carroll Show on 700 WLW on November 11, 2026. “I hold the main blame on GOP members of Congress,” he said.
Topics Covered
- Thune Is Still Making Excuses
- Not Pro-GOP
- Stephen Miller Is the Right Chief of Staff
- No New Immigration Law Is Needed
- Democrats Will Use Power to Punish
- Key Takeaways
Thune Is Still Making Excuses
The day after senators got back to Washington, Thune went to the Senate floor and said Republicans want to work with their Democrat colleagues. In an interview with Bret Baier he repeated that nothing can get done in the Senate because of 60 votes. Most of that is a lie. Whatever is worth doing is worth going through the challenge of doing, and he is not willing.
Some Republicans are now urging action in the weeks that are left. The House Freedom Caucus put out a good statement of what ought to get done. If Congress acts, in Pfaff’s words, “they ought to work their butts off all the way to January 3rd and never leave the dang town.” The obvious question follows. Could they have won the election, or at least not lost so badly, if they had done something in all the months before?
Mike Johnson at least had the dignity to say the House had to move on from him. Thune did the opposite. Mollie Hemingway of The Federalist wrote that John Thune as minority leader is an existential problem for America, and she is right.
“They don’t give a damn what you think. They only care about the checks that can be written to them.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
Members love the $174,000 a year paycheck. They love more the thought of what comes after: a lobbying firm, $300,000 or $400,000 a year and sometimes much more, for getting people in a door and showing up at a PAC fundraiser two or three nights a week. That is what they are protecting when they keep this system going, $40 trillion in debt later, while the Federal Reserve prints money and prices rise on people trying to buy a home or fill a gas tank.
Not Pro-GOP
Pfaff told his staff after the election, “we are not going to be pro-GOP.” The Democrat Party is the obvious opponent. But “the Republican Party is a waste and a mess,” and it cannot be defended as it stands.
More than 54 Republicans lost their seats this cycle. With one or two exceptions, Scott Perry of Pennsylvania among them, losing them is a chance to cull the herd and run people in those districts who believe in this country.
This is how the place works. Tim Huelskamp won the 1st District of Kansas in the Tea Party wave of 2010, and Pfaff became his chief of staff. Huelskamp grew up on a farm, farmed all his life, and wrote his doctoral paper at American University on the Agriculture Committee and farm policy. John Boehner kicked him off the Agriculture Committee anyway. That is what Washington does to a member who does not toe the line.
Stephen Miller Is the Right Chief of Staff
Naming Stephen Miller chief of staff is a good sign. He is sharp, capable and skilled, and he understands the politics. Miller says his focus is winning back young men and the other parts of the coalition that Republicans failed. The one worry is the 60 Minutes interview in which Donald Trump seemed to indicate he would make a deal with Democrats on amnesty. That was reported two hours before he fired Susie Wiles.
No New Immigration Law Is Needed
Some Republicans now say Congress should rewrite immigration law while the border is closed, before Democrats act. Pfaff’s answer is short: “We don’t need to do a dang thing about it.” The laws are already there. The 1986 deal in which Ronald Reagan wrongly gave amnesty also put strong laws in place, and more have been added since. Nobody is saying Donald Trump violated the law. The Democrat message is only that ICE has been horrible to people, and ICE is doing its job and doing it well.
If Democrats push amnesty, the pendulum will swing back on them in 2028. Americans want to stop paying $50 to $70 to fill a 17-gallon tank. They will try one party and then the other, and they will whipsaw Washington until it changes.
John Fetterman has seen it. He is no conservative, but he believes the country and what the American people need come first. He has little chance in a Democrat primary and would do well to run as an independent.
Democrats Will Use Power to Punish
The next two years in Congress will be a fiasco every single day. Democrats are already saying what they will be about: punishing any person ever associated with Donald Trump. Some investigations may need to be done, and if they find something, fine. That is not what Democrats say they want. They want to destroy people’s lives for holding a political opinion and advancing it through the processes the Constitution designed.
That is a violation of federal law. It carries up to five years in prison, and the speech and debate protection does not cover a member who is breaking the law. The Justice Department has already told senators to keep their records. It should follow through.
The Democrat Party is now a red-green alliance of socialists and Islamists, and it is not an American party. One thing drives everything it does.
“They hate Trump more than they love America.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
The Constitution has lasted longer than any other country’s. “We still have the foundation. We just have to rebuild the building on top of the foundation.” Voters rejected the Democrat agenda in 2024, and they can do it again as quickly as they punished Republican neglect this year. Watch the full interview above.
Key Takeaways
- Thune Is Still Making Excuses – The day after senators got back to Washington, Thune went to the Senate floor and said Republicans want to work with their Democrat colleagues.
- Not Pro-GOP – Pfaff told his staff after the election, “we are not going to be pro-GOP.” The Democrat Party is the obvious opponent.
- Stephen Miller Is the Right Chief of Staff – Naming Stephen Miller chief of staff is a good sign.
- No New Immigration Law Is Needed – Some Republicans now say Congress should rewrite immigration law while the border is closed, before Democrats act.
- Democrats Will Use Power to Punish – The next two years in Congress will be a fiasco every single day.
Share This Analysis
Join The Conservative Caucus
Help us fight for election integrity and expose government corruption. Your support makes investigative journalism like this possible.
DONATE TODAYAbout The Conservative Caucus:
The Conservative Caucus is a grassroots public policy action organization, formed in 1974. Headed by President Jim Pfaff, the Caucus is committed to advancing free enterprise, limited government, and traditional values.
Originally broadcast Nov 11, 2026 on The Dan Carroll Show.
Peter J. Thomas is a veteran conservative political strategist and seasoned policy expert dedicated to upholding the principles of the Constitution and democracy. As a founder and the chairman of the Conservative Caucus, he has played a pivotal role in promoting and shaping the conservative agenda across the nation for over half a century.