The Save America Act Was the Republican Congress’s Biggest Miss: Jim Pfaff on The Breakdown with David Gokhshtein | Nov 9, 2026
Published: November 9, 2026
Network: The Breakdown
Analysis: Conservative Caucus President Jim Pfaff
The Save America Act was the biggest miss of the Republican Congress. Voter ID is an issue 80 percent of Americans support. Senate Republicans refused to take it through a real debate, win, lose or draw. Had they done only that, voters would have had something to make them think these people were serious and worth another try.
John Thune spent months saying nothing can be done in the Senate without 60 votes. “That’s actually a lie.” Mike Lee was calling for the filibuster process, which is how legislation actually gets passed. “The 60-vote rule is a way to get out of debate and onto the bill.” Republicans would not do even that.
Jim Pfaff, president of The Conservative Caucus, made the case on The Breakdown with David Gokhshtein on November 9, 2026. He had predicted Republicans would lose 15 to 25 House seats and keep the Senate, and he says he totally missed it. The pollsters Mark Mitchell and Rich Baris were right. The real issue was a Republican Congress that was feckless, useless and unwilling to do anything the American people wanted.
Topics Covered
- How the House Got Around the Senate
- Why Voter ID Does Not Pass
- Money Did Not Save Them
- The 2028 Field
- Vengeance Politics and the Lame Duck
- Key Takeaways
How the House Got Around the Senate
The SAVE Act came out in the spring of 2025, and Mitch McConnell kept it hidden in committee for months. Chip Roy and others then rewrote the bill to be stronger. The House replaced the text of a Senate bill that had already cleared committee with the language of the Save America Act and sent it back, bypassing McConnell altogether.
Mike Johnson deserves credit for going along with that and getting the members on board. It is about the only credit he has earned. He is marginally better than Paul Ryan, Kevin McCarthy and John Boehner.
After the One Big Beautiful Bill passed in the middle of 2025, Congress did nothing else. The one thing it passed was a housing bill that expanded government and that nobody cared about. Everything else it did took care of lobbyists and people in Washington.
Why Voter ID Does Not Pass
Democrats do not want voter ID because the lack of it helps them. California gives driver’s licenses to illegal aliens by law, and that license gets used whatever the citizenship rules say. Whether this election was stolen cannot be said. Americans were truly angry. But a lot of illegal aliens may have voted, certainly in California.
Republicans do not pass it because they are cowards. They are afraid of what the media, and the Democrats the media puts on the air, will say about them. Pfaff’s advice to members who cannot stand being criticized on MS NOW and CNN: “if you can’t handle it, you’re in the wrong business.”
The same fear keeps Obamacare in place. Democrats knew in 2010 that they would lose badly for passing it, and they passed it anyway. Republicans will not repeal it because they dread being told people will lose coverage. Most people who lacked coverage before Obamacare lacked it by choice. “We don’t fix risk with government programs.” A free market that gives people more choices does that.
Some members are simply tied to lobbyists. Bill Cassidy lost his primary because he was bought into the pharmaceutical industry. Too many Republicans have a ring in their nose, and they hold positions of leadership. Tim Huelskamp, Pfaff’s former boss, was one of four members thrown off their committees for refusing to play that game.
Money Did Not Save Them
Republicans had the money this year and Democrats did not. It made no difference, because “there is no direct correlation to having more money and winning.” Hardly any Republican candidates campaigned on what Americans cared about. Donald Trump was the one out campaigning for them.
The war was not the problem in the public’s mind. The exit polls say affordability, which Republicans could not counter and Democrats pushed with no intention of delivering. The average American pays about $50 a week to fill a 17-gallon tank in a car he can barely afford. Good economic numbers do not overcome that.
Trump’s concern about Iran was understandable, and it took courage to act knowing it would hurt in the midterms. Strategically, though, “he absolutely should have waited until after the election to do it.”
The 2028 Field
In Pfaff’s phrase, “Donald Trump is always in apprentice mode” with the people around him, and that includes JD Vance. Trump does not dislike Vance. He listened to him on Iran and tried the diplomatic route first.
The 2028 nomination is wide open. A dozen or more may try, but the real players are JD Vance, Marco Rubio and Ron DeSantis. Rubio has the best case: he is an excellent communicator, he inspires people, and he speaks Spanish like a native. DeSantis is a very close second. Both have built presidential campaigns before, and a failed campaign teaches a great deal. Vance has the vice presidency but not the best case right now. Rand Paul is a possibility too. Brian Darling, a board member of The Conservative Caucus who once worked for Paul, has made that argument in print. None of this is an endorsement.
Vengeance Politics and the Lame Duck
Thomas Massie’s impeachment articles against Pete Hegseth are cowardly, because Hegseth does not make the decisions. War powers belong to Congress. But the War Powers Resolution of 1973 gives a president certain authority, and Trump complied with it entirely, including the 60-day window. “That’s vengeance politics, which we have way too much of.”
The lame duck is the test. The good Republican members want Congress in session every day until January 3. Democrats will end the filibuster when they take over, so there is a decent argument for Republicans to end it now and pass the right things first, though Thom Tillis, Lisa Murkowski and Mitch McConnell will fight that. The House Freedom Caucus has published an agenda worth reading. In Pfaff’s words to his own party, “you can sort of redeem yourselves by getting off your butts and getting to work right now.” Watch the full interview above.
Key Takeaways
- How the House Got Around the Senate – The SAVE Act came out in the spring of 2025, and Mitch McConnell kept it hidden in committee for months.
- Why Voter ID Does Not Pass – Democrats do not want voter ID because the lack of it helps them.
- Money Did Not Save Them – Republicans had the money this year and Democrats did not.
- The 2028 Field – In Pfaff’s phrase, “Donald Trump is always in apprentice mode” with the people around him, and that includes JD Vance.
- Vengeance Politics and the Lame Duck – Thomas Massie’s impeachment articles against Pete Hegseth are cowardly, because Hegseth does not make the decisions.
Share This Analysis
Join The Conservative Caucus
Help us fight for election integrity and expose government corruption. Your support makes investigative journalism like this possible.
DONATE TODAYAbout The Conservative Caucus:
The Conservative Caucus is a grassroots public policy action organization, formed in 1974. Headed by President Jim Pfaff, the Caucus is committed to advancing free enterprise, limited government, and traditional values.
Originally broadcast Nov 9, 2026 on The Breakdown with David Gokhshtein.
Peter J. Thomas is a veteran conservative political strategist and seasoned policy expert dedicated to upholding the principles of the Constitution and democracy. As a founder and the chairman of the Conservative Caucus, he has played a pivotal role in promoting and shaping the conservative agenda across the nation for over half a century.