The Mark Kelly Tax Plan and the Democrats’ Old Playbook: Jim Pfaff on The Dan Carroll Show | Oct 7, 2026
Published: October 7, 2026
Network: 700 WLW
Analysis: Conservative Caucus President Jim Pfaff
Dan Carroll told his 700 WLW audience on October 7, 2026 that he believed early voting had started in Ohio that day, which put them knee-deep in the political season. He opened the Wednesday night edition of The Dan Carroll Show with Conservative Caucus President Jim Pfaff and a complaint: he is tired of hearing the word affordability. Then he played Arizona Sen. Mark Kelly’s answer on Face the Nation, the Mark Kelly tax plan to raise taxes on incomes over $1 million, and asked Pfaff whether Kelly was working from an outdated copy of the playbook. From there the two turned to Abdul El-Sayed and the DSA in Michigan, and to Jim Jordan, Jack Smith and the federal courts.
Topics Covered
- Affordability, the Word Everyone Is Using
- 21% Inflation Under Biden and 2–3% Since
- The Mark Kelly Tax Plan on Face the Nation
- You Don’t Tax Any Country Into Prosperity
- El-Sayed, Obama and the DSA Ick Factor
- Jim Jordan, Jack Smith and the Federal Courts
- Key Takeaways
Affordability, the Word Everyone Is Using
Pfaff, calling in from Indiana, said he senses a mild tide turning, and that Donald Trump being back on the trail makes him feel pretty good. Carroll had texted him earlier in the day about the word affordability. Every debate clip he has seen uses it, Republican and Democrat alike, and he called it the most workshopped phrase the political class could come up with: gibberish, meaningless, drivel. The last thing he looks to a politician for, he said, is legislation to make his groceries, his gasoline or new windows for his house cost less.
“Kind of like Zohran Mamdani destroying all the grocery stores so he can do it through government,” Pfaff answered. Then he gave the part of the complaint he considers fair.
“The one issue on the affordability thing that is fair to say is that people are showing up at the gas station once or twice a week and they’re paying $20 more than they were some time back, even back to the beginning of the year, $15, $20 more each time they fill up. And that’s frustrating. That’s the honest side of this.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
TCC covered the same fight over the word in Pfaff’s analysis of midterm affordability and Republican risk.
21% Inflation Under Biden and 2–3% Since
“But let’s be real about what’s really going on,” Pfaff said. He is not for presidents blaming their predecessor so much, he said, but in this case the blame is real.
“Donald Trump stemmed the tide of a massive inflation wave that we had to endure in the Biden administration. We’ve been hovering around 2-3% inflation. That’s actually pretty normal since Donald Trump became president because he immediately stopped the bleeding by turning back all the Biden executive orders that played a major role in price inflation.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
What remains, he said, is the general inflation that comes with massive government spending, which Washington has not dealt with. Trump has some culpability for that, but not a lot compared to the overall.
The Numbers Pfaff Cited
A federal budget in the $4.5 trillion range in 2019, before COVID, followed by massive COVID spending. 21% inflation during the Biden years; around 2–3% since Trump became president. At the pump, $15 to $20 more per fill-up than at the beginning of the year.
“And yet you’ve got these Democrats out there talking about affordability, and the bulk of that problem lay with them,” Pfaff said. “And yet Donald Trump’s the bad guy here.”
Carroll agreed: under Joe Biden the country was going back to the Jimmy Carter days of stagflation and the misery index, “and we forget that so quickly.”
The Mark Kelly Tax Plan on Face the Nation
Then Carroll played a sound bite Pfaff had posted: Kelly on the Sunday show Face the Nation, trying to deal with the affordability issue. This is the Mark Kelly tax plan in the senator’s own words.
“Well, we’re going to lower costs for the American people. We’ve got to win the House and/or the Senate. Well, how will we do this? I have legislation with Chris Van Hollen. We’ve got to get Republicans on board. Raises taxes for people who make over $1 million a year in income, and it provides tax cuts for individuals and even couples who make up to about $160,000 a year. That’s some relief.”
— Sen. Mark Kelly, Face the Nation, as played on The Dan Carroll Show
Carroll’s verdict on the Mark Kelly tax plan came before Pfaff could answer.
“Jim, does this guy just have an outdated copy of the playbook? How are you going to do that? Well, we’re going to tax the rich. That’s going to make everything more affordable. And that’s one of the dumbest answers I’ve ever heard.”
— Dan Carroll, Host, The Dan Carroll Show
“It’s an incredibly stupid answer,” Pfaff said, and he ran the math on the extreme version of the Mark Kelly tax plan.
“So let’s say that they took all the wealth of the rich and just confiscated it. You paid for the federal budget for one year.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
Democrats are talking about wealth confiscation as well, he noted. To do it, you would have to sell all the companies, “because wealthy people aren’t wealthy in cash. They’re wealthy in assets.” Is the federal government going to buy them? He offered it as the extreme example; his larger point was that you don’t tax anybody into prosperity.
You Don’t Tax Any Country Into Prosperity
“You don’t tax any country into prosperity. That is not how prosperity works. Prosperity works by allowing people to go order their lives in a way that will be productive for them. Wealth comes from people having an opportunity to be productive.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
The regulatory state that expanded enormously under Joe Biden, Pfaff said, was a basic foundation for the economic malaise of his presidency. No government program makes people wealthy or comfortable or gives them things like health insurance, he said; that comes when government is out of the way and people can choose what they want to pay for. “That is what grows a country,” he said. “You can’t tax people enough.”
“If he’s talking about taxes, you talk about the old playbook. This is literally: I’m going to tax certain people, give the money to other people. And what does that do? Literally nothing, particularly when you consider the fraud that we now know exists in a deep manner in government programs.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
Government programs are inefficient and cost more than letting people do these things voluntarily, he said, and that includes welfare and taking care of people who find themselves in a bad state; all of it is done better in the private markets and in private charity. Government has a near monopoly on charity and total control over many industries, and everything it does makes the big players stronger and puts anyone trying to compete against them in second place. That, Pfaff said, is what the Mark Kelly tax plan does.
People are rejecting the Mark Kelly tax plan, he said. His post of the Kelly clip is the biggest he has put up in months; it skyrocketed, and every comment on it shows people know the answer is stupid. “That gives me hope for the American people,” he said. The problem is that people who go into politics think, as Carroll said, that they can pass a bill to fix things.
“Laws don’t fix things. Not to mention the fact that we’re so far beyond our constitutional limits of what Congress can do right now. And that’s a big one to try to bite off as quickly as we can, hopefully. It’s going to be a challenge.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
Carroll said the Mark Kelly tax plan answer showed Kelly was woefully unprepared. It was the gentlest pushback he could have gotten, Carroll said, and Kelly “panicked and went back to the old crutch. Well, I’ve got a plan to raise taxes.” That is politics 101, Carroll said, and Kelly couldn’t handle it. Pfaff’s reply: “Politics, we need ideas.”
El-Sayed, Obama and the DSA Ick Factor
Carroll turned to Michigan, where he said Abdul El-Sayed is becoming the central character of the midterm elections. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, working on becoming the Democrat front-runner much to the chagrin of Kamala Harris and Pete Buttigieg, is essentially saying an El-Sayed win shows she has the chops to win on the same red-green alliance platform. And Barack Obama is coming out to campaign with El-Sayed on the 24th of this month. After the phone line dropped and Pfaff came back on, Carroll asked whether that weds the Democrat Party to the whole DSA red-green alliance.
“It does,” Pfaff said. “And in fact, they’re already wedded to it.” The reason it is rising in the Democrat Party, he said, is that this is what the party has been about since Obama, who had a light touch on it at first. He pointed to the NGO problem, all the money flowing through government to leftist political actors, and then the rise of the Squad.
“I don’t know what the outcome of the election is going to be, but I do believe that the DSA ick factor is settling into a lot of people’s minds. And that’s why I think El-Sayed is going to lose in Michigan. I think Mike Rogers is going to pull that out. Through a whisker.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
“Not that I’m a big fan of Mike Rogers,” he added. A Rogers win, he said, would make Ocasio-Cortez give her final decision, which he thinks she has already made, to run for Senate in New York, where she probably will be the next senator, taking out Chuck Schumer, who he said will likely retire if she does that. TCC tracked the Michigan race earlier in Pfaff’s analysis of Michigan as the DSA’s next test case.
Democrats are marrying themselves to this ideology, Pfaff said, and he believes strongly the American people will reject it, even more so in 2028, when he expects a booming economy: the Iran War done, gas prices down, and artificial intelligence making small businesses more effective. If Democrats keep wedding themselves to it, he said, they could be done.
Jim Jordan, Jack Smith and the Federal Courts
Carroll’s last item was a Just the News headline from John Solomon: Jim Jordan renews calls to prosecute Jack Smith after a review of spying on Susie Wiles’ phone records. Carroll said Jordan, a very capable guy, needs to give it a rest: so many hearings and headlines, all talk and no action.
Pfaff considers Jordan a personal friend and has great respect for him, and said Jordan has done a better job than Trey Gowdy. (“That’s not a very high bar,” Carroll said. “Yeah, that’s true,” Pfaff answered.) His point was about what Congress can do.
“The reality is that Congress can only make referrals. They can’t get things done. That’s got to happen through the Department of Justice. And if that’s not happening, then do move on to something else.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
As Judiciary Chairman, Pfaff said, Jordan could deal with radical leftist courts that get by with things. He called it very helpful that there was a serious throwdown on Minnesota judges he said were literally colluding with one another to go after Donald Trump and publicly talking about cases; the DOJ, he said, is looking at that and has referred things up. The next step for the Judiciary Committee, in his view, is what Newt Gingrich has talked about for years: eliminate and restructure some of the federal court systems and get rid of the bad judges in them. And Jack Smith, he said, needs to be prosecuted because he did break the law. Carroll agreed.
“But the reality is that we’ve got to restructure our court system because that is the greatest future threat that we have in this country, in my opinion.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus
Carroll closed by saying he likes Jordan but that Jordan has underdelivered, and it is going to hurt him in the long run.
Key Takeaways
- The honest side of affordability – Pfaff said drivers paying $15 to $20 more per fill-up is fair to complain about, but the bulk of the inflation problem lies with Democrats.
- 21% versus 2–3% – Pfaff said Trump stopped the bleeding by turning back Biden’s executive orders; government spending is still not dealt with.
- The Mark Kelly tax plan – Kelly’s answer on Face the Nation was to raise taxes on incomes over $1 million; Carroll called it an outdated copy of the playbook and Pfaff called it an incredibly stupid answer.
- Confiscation pays for one year – Taking all the wealth of the rich would pay the federal budget for one year, Pfaff said, and you don’t tax any country into prosperity.
- The DSA ick factor – Pfaff said Democrats are already wedded to the DSA and predicted Mike Rogers beats Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan by a whisker.
- Restructure the courts – Congress can only make referrals, Pfaff said; Jim Jordan’s Judiciary Committee should take up restructuring the federal courts, the greatest future threat in his opinion.
Share This Analysis
Join The Conservative Caucus
Help us fight for election integrity and expose government corruption. Your support makes investigative journalism like this possible.
DONATE TODAYAbout The Conservative Caucus:
The Conservative Caucus is a grassroots public policy action organization, formed in 1974. Headed by President Jim Pfaff, the Caucus is committed to advancing free enterprise, limited government, and traditional values.
Originally broadcast Oct 7, 2026 on The Dan Carroll Show with Dan Carroll, 700 WLW.
Peter J. Thomas is a veteran conservative political strategist and seasoned policy expert dedicated to upholding the principles of the Constitution and democracy. As a founder and the chairman of the Conservative Caucus, he has played a pivotal role in promoting and shaping the conservative agenda across the nation for over half a century.