Democrats Broke the Safeguards That Kept Voter Rolls Clean: Jim Pfaff on Bobby Gunther Walsh | Oct 29, 2026
Published: October 29, 2026
Network: WAEB Allentown
Analysis: Conservative Caucus President Jim Pfaff
On Bobby Gunther Walsh, Conservative Caucus President Jim Pfaff said Democrats broke the systems that once kept voter rolls relatively clean, from two decades of court-driven rule changes to mail ballots that wreck custody.
The hour opened on Alaska. He called a recruited second Dan Sullivan an outrage, then carried the same charge through California’s rolls, a Mark Wayne Mullin clip, and a Brazil runoff he said changed the rules in the middle of the game.
Topics Covered
- A Second Dan Sullivan on the Alaska Ballot
- California Indictments and Rolls That No Longer Get Checked
- Mail Voting and the Loss of Ballot Custody
- The Safeguards That Used to Stop Most Abuse
- Brazil, and a Rule Change in the Middle of the Game
- What He Told Listeners to Do Tuesday
A Second Dan Sullivan on the Alaska Ballot
The host brought up a New York Times report that Mary Peltola’s campaign was behind an effort to find and recruit a candidate named Dan Sullivan to run against Sen. Dan Sullivan. Pfaff said same-name candidacies show up mostly in local races, and only rarely in Congress.
He read the Alaska move as proof Democrats thought a second Dan Sullivan was their only hope for the seat. “This is absolutely an outrage and an absurdity.” He said they had planned it and then tried to say they had not. “In other words, they lied.”
He said he was not sure which federal or local statute applied. “But the reality is it’s immoral and it is playing the game in an unfair manner.” Democrats, he said, had been searching the voter rolls for a Democrat named Dan Sullivan they could put on the ballot against the real Dan Sullivan. The man who took the spot, he said, acted under auspices that were absurd and immoral.
The opening he offered Republicans was political, not technical. If they promote the MAGA agenda and the constitutional conservatism that has been the party’s foundation for decades, more than nearly a century, he said they can win. “Democrats walk in fear.”
He said many Washington Republicans are scared of Democrats, including John Thune “twiddling his thumbs over the Save America Act.” Donald Trump’s national career over the last 10 years, he said, shows voters will back an agenda that is about them. “Republicans have been weak-kneed quite often about this, and they should have pushed on this much harder earlier.” A local move to pull the false Dan Sullivan off the ballot failed when a local court refused. “We really have a problem with the rule of law as well, as far as it goes with these matters.” Anger is fitting, he said, and “we really have the power if we’re willing to wield it,” because Democrats knew they could not win without cheating and voters align more with Republican ideas.
California Indictments and Rolls That No Longer Get Checked
Asked about fresh California indictments, Pfaff said a prosecutor had just issued grand jury indictments of people illegally registered to vote who lied on their applications. He placed that in a wider roll problem.
California, he said, is fighting a legitimate finding of about 20,000 illegals on the ballot, and he believes the number is larger. Citizens who fail to report a move and then vote a ballot from an old address, in the state or out of it, are violating the law too.
He tied the dirty play to Norm Eisen and Marc Elias spending two decades using the courts to change the rules. States used to check that citizens were at their proper voting address. The rolls were never perfect, he said, but the process was a system. “Now that system doesn’t exist.”
Blue states all over the country are refusing to clean their ballots.
Mail Voting and the Loss of Ballot Custody
Pfaff said mail voting was built to take advantage of those rolls. In California, he said, any activist can gather as many mail ballots as they want and bring them in for the voter.
That breaks what he called the old virtue of the system. Custody of the ballot gets messed up. It also allows pressure at the doorstep, someone asking whether you are going to vote a certain way. Same-day voting at a physical polling place, he said, never allowed that.
The Safeguards That Used to Stop Most Abuse
After the host played Mark Wayne Mullin on noncitizens and deceased people still on the rolls, Pfaff stepped back from any claim of a perfect election. Elections are a human institution, he said. Errors will be made, and some people will abuse whatever system they are given.
All of that has been broken down because of what Democrats have done, particularly in blue states.
He said the same failure can show up in red states. He called Brad Raffensperger in Georgia the poster child of a red-state election official who let a system go awry. In blue states, he said, the point is to consolidate and hold power. Democrats cannot tell voters what they will do to make life better.
Most Americans, he said, even with some growth of these ideas among young people, do not accept socialism and communism. They argue over social programs, and they still want to live without the government obstructing what they are trying to do. That, he said, is an argument Democrats cannot make.
Brazil, and a Rule Change in the Middle of the Game
Pfaff said he knows the Bolsonaro family, has a signed t-shirt from Jair Bolsonaro, and counts Eduardo Bolsonaro, in exile, as a friend. He had emailed Conservative Caucus supporters about Brazil that day. He had already joked that Joe Biden “won Brazil by 81 million votes” because something went wrong so blatantly.
Brazil, he said, uses a runoff when no one wins a majority, a system a handful of American states also use. In early October, under what he called weird circumstances, Flávio Bolsonaro did not break 50% and got a little over 49%. Pfaff believes Flávio had 5 million more votes than sitting president Lula da Silva, so the race went to a runoff on the 25th.
He said Flávio led through the night, the count tightened, and Flávio was slightly ahead as the polls were going to close at 5 PM. Brazil’s elections are run by the Superior Electoral Court, the TSE. The TSE did not change the rules, he said. A judge on that court ordered the polls kept open for 2 more hours.
Many polls had already closed in areas that supported Flávio Bolsonaro. Pfaff said those places use Dominion machines that cannot be reopened once they are closed. Areas helpful to Lula stayed open for those 2 hours. The judge who ordered it, he said, was Lula’s personal lawyer in the Lava Jato case that sent Lula to jail for 20 years, and that same court later freed Lula to run against Jair Bolsonaro in 2022. He called Bolsonaro’s 2022 loss suspicious.
“And here we have a total change of the rules in the middle of the game.” He called Brazil a more severe form of the problem he had described in the United States. Americans are partly insulated, he said, because elections are split across 50 states, a Constitution still applies, and a legal process exists that Brazil does not have in the same way.
What He Told Listeners to Do Tuesday
Asked whether Brazil is a picture of what might happen here on Tuesday, Pfaff said he does not know how much of a reflection it is. It is a reflection, he said, of what will happen in the future if Republicans do not get out to vote Tuesday and try to keep as many Republicans in Congress as possible.
Key Takeaways
- Broken safeguards: Pfaff said the old checks that kept voter rolls relatively clean have been broken down, particularly in blue states.
- About 20,000: He said California is fighting a finding of about 20,000 illegals on the ballot, and that citizens who vote from an old address break the law too.
- Two decades: He blamed Norm Eisen and Marc Elias for two decades of using the courts to change voting rules.
- Mail ballots: He said mail voting was built to exploit dirty rolls and that third-party collection breaks ballot custody.
- Alaska: He called recruiting another Dan Sullivan immoral and unfair, and said a local court left that name on the ballot.
- Brazil: He said a judge kept some polls open 2 more hours after Flávio Bolsonaro areas had closed, a mid-game rule change.
- Tuesday: He told Republicans to vote Tuesday and try to keep as many Republicans in Congress as possible.
Share This Analysis
Join The Conservative Caucus
Help us fight for election integrity and expose government corruption. Your support makes investigative journalism like this possible.
About The Conservative Caucus:
The Conservative Caucus is a grassroots public policy action organization, formed in 1974. Headed by President Jim Pfaff, the Caucus is committed to advancing free enterprise, limited government, and traditional values.
Originally broadcast Oct 29, 2026 on Bobby Gunther Walsh.
Peter J. Thomas is a veteran conservative political strategist and seasoned policy expert dedicated to upholding the principles of the Constitution and democracy. As a founder and the chairman of the Conservative Caucus, he has played a pivotal role in promoting and shaping the conservative agenda across the nation for over half a century.